Tucked away at the crossroads of Holland Street and Broadway, Teele Square may not boast the bustling fame of Davis or Union Square, but ask anyone who’s wandered its streets at dinnertime and you’ll hear rave reviews. From nationally-lauded bagels to cozy neighborhood pubs and late-night bites, Teele Square offers a clustered, yet eclectic food scene with something genuinely special for every palate and budget. Hungry to explore? Here’s where to eat like a local in Teele Square.
Morning Bites and Coffee Stops
The day in Teele Square starts strong with a seriously passionate coffee culture and some of the best bagels you’ll find outside of NYC.
- Bagelsaurus (1796 Massachusetts Ave, a quick walk from Teele): A must-visit for carb enthusiasts. These hand-rolled, fermented bagels have achieved legendary status in the Boston area. Lines form early for seasonal schmears, inventive fillings (don’t miss the Hot Smoked Salmon Sandwich), and the elusive egg bagels. The vibe is simple and friendly—perfect in the morning or as a quick lunch stop. Expect to spend $5–$12.
- True Grounds (717 Broadway): Just steps from the square’s main intersection, this beloved café serves up reliably creamy lattes, creative house-made pastries (try the scones!), and light lunches. Outlets and Wi-Fi make it a remote work favorite and weekend brunch staple, usually under $15.
Lunch Favorites: From Classic to International
Noontime in Teele Square provides a global passport—no fancy dress code or reservations required.
- Pizzeria Regina (71 Holland St): While the North End might steal the limelight, this offshoot of the Boston classic has a fiercely loyal local following. Known for thin, chewy crusts, fresh toppings, and timeless cheese pizzas, you can grab a big slice or share a pie, all in the $12–$20 range.
- Sabur (212 Holland St): For a casual lunch with Mediterranean flair, Sabur is the neighborhood’s go-to. Their housemade pita, rich hummus, and Balkan specialties (think grilled lamb and sophisticated vegetarian plates) make every meal feel like an escape. Lunch plates hover around $15, and the lush back patio is a warm-weather gem.
- Zoe’s Restaurant (3080 Massachusetts Ave): Just across the line into Cambridge but a perennial Teele Square lunch destination, Zoe’s offers Greek diner classics—gyro platters, spanakopita, Greek salads—and all-day breakfast. Reliable, comforting, and never overpriced.
Dinner Destinations: Standouts for Every Taste
When the evening hits, Teele Square’s diverse kitchens shine brightest—whether you’re seeking a casual bite, family-style meal, or date-night destination.
- PJ Ryan’s (239 Holland St): Maybe the ultimate “everyone’s welcome” pub—Irish stews, rotating taps, spicy wings, and famous burgers fill this charming spot nightly. Modest prices ($10–$18 entrees), trivia nights, and friendly staff keep the crowd merry.
- House of Kebab (237 Elm St): This underrated Persian gem serves up the city’s most aromatic kebabs, fluffy saffron rice, and savory stews. Don’t miss their koobideh or crispy tahdig. Entrees are generous and mostly under $20—perfect for sharing.
- Mamma Lisa’s Pizzeria and Trattoria (220 Holland St): Authentic Italian cuisine is alive and well at this low-key local favorite. The creamy lasagna, blistered brick-oven pizzas, garlicky white clam pies, and silky gelato are worth repeat visits. Dinners range from $12–$25.
- Angelina’s (301 Highland Ave): Another homey, old-school Italian spot, famed for huge portions of chicken parm, baked pasta, and pizza. You’ll dine surrounded by regulars and feel like you’ve discovered a neighborhood secret.
Sweet Treats and Hidden Gems
If you need a pick-me-up or that elusive after-dinner sweet, Teele Square’s got you covered.
- Petsi Pies (Pie Bakery & Café) (285 Beacon St): A short stroll southeast brings you to this heaven for homemade pies—both sweet and savory. Their chocolate bourbon pecan and apple crumble pies draw citywide fans. Individual slices run $5–$7. Get there before they sell out most afternoons!
- Taco Party (711 Broadway): A vegan food truck turned vibrant brick-and-mortar, Taco Party dishes wild flavors—smoky tempeh tacos, crunchy “fish” tacos, and house-made sodas. Even non-vegans rave about the crispy potato taco. Expect to spend about $12–$16 for a hearty meal.
- Posto Mobile and Food Trucks (regularly in Teele Square): On most weekends and during local events, you’ll find food truck favorites like Posto Mobile dishing out wood-fired pizzas or seasonal trucks with gourmet grilled cheese. Keep an eye out near the intersection of Holland and Broadway.
Food Traditions, Culture, and Neighborhood Vibes
Part of what makes Teele so distinct is the neighborly energy and low-key charm—no pretentious waits or dress codes, just excellent food and a genuine welcome. Every spring and summer, impromptu street fests bring extra food carts and tents from local businesses to the square, feeding the afternoon crowds. You’ll spot families piling into classic pizzerias, grad students poring over laptops at coffee shops, and friends sharing meze late into the night.
Teele Square isn’t just a pit stop between Davis and Alewife; it’s a destination in its own right for intrepid eaters seeking both comfort classics and inventive fare. With everything clustered around the main intersection of Holland Street, Broadway, and local side streets, you’re never far from your next memorable bite.
Plan Your Culinary Crawl
Want to eat like a true local? Here’s my tried-and-true tour for first-timers:
1. Start with breakfast at Bagelsaurus (go for a special sandwich if you’re feeling adventurous).
2. Grab a midday coffee and pastry at True Grounds.
3. Lunch with friends at Sabur—order small plates to share.
4. Explore the afternoon snack scene with a slice from Petsi Pies or Taco Party tacos.
5. Cap off the night with dinner at Mamma Lisa’s, then wind down at PJ Ryan’s for a pint and local stories.
Whether you’re craving old-school comfort food or a creative, plant-based feast, Teele Square’s dining scene promises to surprise and satisfy. Next time you find yourself in Somerville—skip the lines in Davis and discover your new favorite spot in Teele.